Journaling

Journaling is not one activity. The word covers at least five practices with different purposes, different formats and different failure modes, and confusing them is the main reason people conclude it does not work for them.

The main forms:

• Diary or daily record — What happened. Its value is retrospective and accumulates slowly — a year in is when it starts being interesting. Low effort per entry, and the easiest to sustain.
• Reflective journaling — What you thought about what happened. Longer entries, less frequent, and the form most people mean when they say journaling helped them think something through.
• Bullet journaling — A structured system of short logged lines, indexes and migrated tasks, functioning as planner and record together. The most practical, and the form most vulnerable to being taken over by decoration.
• Morning pages — Three pages of longhand written on waking without stopping or editing, from Julia Cameron’s The Artist’s Way. Deliberately unread afterwards; the point is clearing rather than recording.
• Commonplace book — A collection of quotations, extracts and notes from what you read, organised by theme. A centuries-old scholarly practice and arguably the most durable form.

1. 1

   Step 1: Decide what the journal is for before you buy one

   Record, reflection, planning, creative practice or reading notes. The answer determines the format, the frequency and the notebook, and skipping this is why so many beautiful notebooks have four pages used.

   You will know it worked when: A journal with a job.

2. 2

   Step 2: Set an absurdly low bar

   Three sentences, or one line. A practice that survives a bad week is worth more than one that produces beautiful entries for nine days and then stops. You can always write more; you cannot retroactively write on days you skipped.

   You will know it worked when: A habit that is still alive in month three.

3. 3

   Step 3: Attach it to something you already do

   After brushing your teeth, with the first coffee, on the train. Journaling fails as a free-floating intention and succeeds as an appendix to an existing routine.

   You will know it worked when: You stop having to remember.

4. 4

   Step 4: Use a cheap notebook first

   An expensive notebook creates pressure to write something worthy of it, which is precisely the pressure that stops people writing. Buy the nice one for volume two.

   You will know it worked when: You write badly, on purpose, which is the only way to start.

5. 5

   Step 5: Date every entry and leave gaps alone

   Do not go back and fill in missed days, and do not start again from the beginning of a new notebook because you missed a fortnight. The gaps are part of the record.

   You will know it worked when: A continuous practice rather than a series of failed attempts.

The blank page is the practical obstacle. A small set of reliable openings removes it:

• Three things that happened — Purely factual, no interpretation. Works on days with nothing to reflect on and takes ninety seconds.
• What am I actually worried about? — Named specifically rather than generally. Often the most useful single question.
• What changed my mind this week? — Produces the entries that are most interesting to reread years later.
• What did I read, and what did I take from it? — Turns a journal into a commonplace book and gives it a second use.
• What would I tell someone else in this situation? — The distancing effect is the point — advice you would give is usually clearer than advice you would take.
• Describe one thing in detail — A room, a walk, a meal. Pure description with no reflection at all, which is both easy and unexpectedly good practice for writing.

There is no advanced journaling, and anybody selling one is selling stationery. What there is instead is a set of directions people move in once the basic practice is stable, and most of them involve doing less rather than more.

1. 1

   Step 1: Get one form stable for three months

   One form, one cadence, no system changes. Three months is roughly where a journal starts to be worth re-reading, which is the first genuine payoff the practice has.

   You will know it worked when: Something worth going back to.

2. 2

   Step 2: Read your own back catalogue

   The step almost nobody takes and the one that changes what they write. Re-reading a year of entries shows you what you actually record and what you have been avoiding.

   You will know it worked when: You know what your journal is for, from evidence.

3. 3

   Step 3: Add a second form for a second purpose

   A daily record and a reflective practice do different jobs and coexist happily; trying to make one do both is why people abandon them. Two thin practices beat one bloated one.

   You will know it worked when: Two habits with distinct purposes.

4. 4

   Step 4: Let the tooling settle

   Paper, app, or both. This is the point at which the choice can be made on evidence rather than on aspiration, because you now know whether you search old entries and whether you write away from a desk.

   You will know it worked when: A medium chosen from how you actually use it.

5. 5

   Step 5: Go sideways into writing, if that is what it was

   A number of people discover the journal was a way into something else — fiction, essays, letters, a commonplace book of things worth keeping. That is a hobby next door rather than a graduation.

   You will know it worked when: A clear idea of whether you want a record or a practice.

One practical caution that is worth stating plainly: writing repeatedly and at length about a distressing event without moving towards any sense of it can entrench rumination rather than relieve it. If journaling consistently leaves you feeling worse, that is useful information about the practice rather than about you, and stopping or changing format is a reasonable response.